Interest-Only vs Repayment Mortgage: Which Suits You Best?

Mortgages are the biggest financial commitment you’ll ever make.

You might be wondering: Can I afford the monthly payments? What are my long-term plans for this property? And, most importantly, which mortgage type suits me best?

In the UK, there are two main repayment methods to choose from—interest-only mortgages and repayment mortgages.

Picking between the two is a big decision because you’ll need to be confident you can manage the payments and get the best deal possible.

If you’re feeling unsure about which route to take, this guide has got your back. 

We’ll walk you through everything you need to know about interest-only and repayment mortgages, so you can decide which one fits your needs best.

Let’s break it all down, so you can make an informed decision and have a great time.

The Difference Between Interest-Only and Repayment Mortgages 

To put it simply, the main difference between repayment and interest-only mortgages is how your monthly payments are structured:

• Repayment Mortgage. Each payment reduces both the capital and the interest. Over time, your debt decreases, and you own more of your home.
• Interest-Only Mortgage. Payments cover just the interest. The debt doesn’t reduce, so you’ll need a plan to pay off the full amount at the end of the term.

This difference affects not just your monthly payments but also your overall financial strategy and risk level. 

Choosing between repayment or interest-only comes down to what suits your current finances and future plans best.

Interest-Only Mortgage vs Repayment: What Else Should You Consider?

Choosing between an interest-only and a repayment mortgage isn’t just about monthly payments. Here are some other factors to keep in mind:

• Your Financial Situation – If you need lower monthly payments now, an interest-only mortgage might be tempting. But remember, you’ll need to be disciplined about saving or investing to cover the final payment.
• Future Plans – If you’re planning to stay in the property long-term and want the security of owning it outright, a repayment mortgage is likely the better choice.
• Investment Strategy – For buy-to-let properties, many landlords prefer interest-only mortgages as they can maximise rental income and potentially sell the property to pay off the loan.

The Pros and Cons

To help you make a more informed choice, let’s explore the pros and cons of each mortgage type in detail.

For Repayment Mortgages

Pros:

• You gradually pay off both the loan and the interest, reducing your debt over time.
• You’ll own your home outright at the end of the term, giving you long-term financial security.
• You pay less interest overall compared to an interest-only mortgage.
• Your mortgage balance decreases, making it easier to qualify for better deals in the future.

Cons:

• Higher monthly payments, which can put more pressure on your budget.
• Less flexibility in managing cash flow since more of your money goes towards the mortgage.
• If you’re financially stretched, it can be challenging to keep up with payments.
• Limited ability to invest elsewhere due to higher mortgage costs.

For Interest-Only Mortgages

Pros:

• Lower monthly payments, freeing up cash for other expenses or investments.
• Greater flexibility in managing your finances, especially if your income fluctuates.
• Can be tax-efficient for buy-to-let investors, as mortgage interest can be offset against rental income.
• Offers a way to manage cash flow during periods of financial uncertainty.

Cons:

• You’ll still owe the full loan amount at the end of the term, requiring a solid repayment plan.
• Higher overall interest costs since the principal doesn’t reduce.
• Stricter lender criteria, including larger deposits and proof of a repayment strategy.
• Risk of financial difficulties if your repayment plan underperforms or market conditions change.

These pros and cons should give you a clearer picture of what to expect from each type of mortgage. Keep these in mind as you decide which one best suits your needs.

Which One Is Best For Me?

The best mortgage option depends on your financial situation and goals.

Repayment Mortgage

If you prioritise owning your home outright and want to pay less interest overall, a repayment mortgage is ideal. 

It’s suitable for those seeking stability and long-term financial security.

Interest-Only Mortgage

If you need lower initial payments and have a solid repayment plan, an interest-only mortgage might be a good fit. 

This option is often preferred by investors or those with fluctuating income who want to free up cash for other investments.

Consider your current budget, future goals, and risk tolerance. If you’re unsure, consulting a qualified mortgage advisor can help you make an informed decision.

Can You Switch Between Interest-Only and Repayment Mortgages?

Yes, you can. If you’ve started with an interest-only mortgage but your situation changes, you might want to switch to a repayment deal, or vice versa. 

Here’s how it typically works:

• Switching to Repayment – You’ll need to show your lender that you can afford the higher monthly payments. This is often easier if your income has increased or if you’ve paid off other debts.
• Switching to Interest-Only – Lenders will want to see a solid repayment plan and might require a larger deposit or more equity in the property.

This flexibility can be a lifesaver if your circumstances change. 

Just keep in mind that switching might involve fees and a new affordability check, so it’s worth consulting a mortgage advisor before making a move.

Should You Overpay an Interest-Only or a Repayment Mortgage?

Overpaying reduces your mortgage debt faster on both types. But it works very differently between interest-only and repayment.

With repayment mortgages, overpayments go straight towards clearing the actual loan balance quicker. This cuts future interest and shortens the mortgage term.

For example, overpaying £200 per month could save £30,000+ in interest over the mortgage life. And you become mortgage-free years earlier.

But with interest-only, overpayments don’t reduce the final lump sum itself. The mortgage length stays the same too.

Instead, overpaid amounts save you money by reducing the interest charges during the mortgage term. But the capital still needs to be repaid at the end.

So, when is overpaying most effective?

• Repayment – overpay to pay off the mortgage faster and debt-free sooner
• Interest-only – overpay to cut the overall cost, not the final repayment

Consider your financial goals when choosing which option is smarter. But either way, overpaying boosts your equity faster.

What Happens If I Can’t Pay Off My Interest-Only Mortgage?

Failing to repay an interest-only mortgage at the end of the term is a serious issue. 

With an interest only, you’ll still owe a large lump sum when the mortgage matures. 

If you can’t afford it, the lender can repossess your home to recoup their money. To avoid this, you need a solid plan to repay the capital upfront. 

Lenders will want proof, such as savings or investments. 

If your plan falls through, you risk losing your home. The lender will likely seek a court order to repossess the property.

Therefore, it’s crucial to regularly review your repayment plan for an interest-only mortgage. Make it a priority to have the funds in place by the time the mortgage matures.

The Bottom Line: Which Mortgage Type is Best for You?

Choosing between an interest-only and a repayment mortgage depends on your financial goals and how comfortable you are with risk. 

If you prefer lower monthly payments and have a solid plan to pay off the loan later, an interest-only mortgage could be a good option.

If you want the security of owning your home outright and a straightforward way to get there, a repayment mortgage is likely the better choice.

Whatever you decide, make sure you understand the long-term impact and have a clear plan for repaying your mortgage. 

If you’re unsure, speaking with a mortgage advisor can help you find the best option for your situation. Get in touch, and we’ll connect you with an expert to guide you through your choices.

Get Matched With Your Dream Mortgage Advisor...

Find out if you qualify today by taking the M-Quotient™ Assessment for FREE!

Find my dream advisor & mortgage

(Won’t impact credit score)